Hanes Comfortwash Garment Dyed Sweatshirt

Pros

• Buyers love how comfortable it is
• Plenty of color options

Cons

• Some buyers report it shrinks after a few washes

Hanes has impressed us before with the perfect T-shirt, and for layering season, it seems the brand has the perfect sweatshirt, too. With this vintage-wash, garment-dyed sweatshirt, the purveyor of all things basic proves that it has other tricks up its (very comfy) sleeve. Plus, it's less than 20 bucks right now—you might as well stock up.

One buyer says: "The fleece is super soft and warm, perfect for lounging around or layering on cooler days. I also really like the garment-dyed look—it gives the sweatshirt a unique, lived-in feel that’s a bit different from the usual."

Amazon Essentials Long-Sleeve Crewneck Fleece Sweatshirt

Pros

• Available in Big and Tall sizes
• Stretchy hem is great for layering

Cons

• Buyers report the arms run long

Turns out, you can get a sweatshirt that's comfortable, soft, and perfectly cozy right from the mega retailer's own brand. This classic crewneck features ribbing on the collar, hem, and cuffs to keep you warm, and it comes in extended sizing, too.

One buyer says: "This sweatshirt is made from nice, soft material, but is lighter-weight than I expected. While it might be technically accurate to call this material 'fleece' since it is a little fuzzy, it bears little resemblance to the much thicker fleece I typically see."

Comfort Colors Crewneck Sweatshirt

Pros

• Double-stitched for durability
• Shoulders roll forward for an improved fit

Cons

• Fabric is on the thinner side

Like Hanes, Comfort Colors is a classic tee maker that also offers stellar sweatshirts that lives up to its name. Our editors love this style for how damn soft it is. Plus, the minimalist look isn't too athletic or dressed down; with some work pants and loafers, you can easily style this bad boy to look a little more expensive than it really is.

One buyer says: "Comfort Colors have great quality crewnecks with unique colors. They hold embroidery remarkably well. They are sturdy and have a vintage look to them. The sizing is unisex and I have not experienced shrinking in the wash. 10/10."

Champion Powerblend Fleece Crew Sweatshirt

Pros

• Fabric designed not to shrink or pill
• Brushed interior for warmth
• Ribbed trims

Cons

• Runs large
• Fleece lining can get too hot

It's hard to beat the classics—and when they still look this good, it's really not worth trying. Champion has made a name for itself in the world of sweatshirts, and for good reason; the brand that invented the hoodie does a crewneck just as well, with a brushed, mid-weight fabric that's never too warm and a perfectly oversize fit that hits just right, every time.

One buyer says: "The sweatshirt is a nice size. I bought the XXL. It sits very light on the torso and fills out very well. This is not a heavyweight, bulky sweatshirt. It's a medium weight. Good structure and incredibly soft. Might be the softest casual wear that I own. Total comfort. The first thing you notice is the incredible pillow like softness. They did a very good job on this one."

Todd Snyder + Champion Midweight Pocket Sweatshirt

Pros

• Moisture-wicking fabric
• Cross-grain cut prevents shrinkage

Cons

• Buyers report it has a slim fit

Todd Snyder makes his sweatshirt in collaboration with classic sportswear giant Champion, so you know it's gonna be good. This one is a favorite, because it's comfy and cozy without being too laid-back; true to Todd Snyder's unendingly chic designs, this sweatshirt has a slightly tailored look, with a soft, brushed fabric and piece-dyed color.

One buyer says: "Well fitting, this is a great way to be comfortable in a sweatshirt, but still neat and stylish. Love the warm brown color too."

Gildan Heavy Blend Crewneck Sweatshirt

Pros

• Double-stitched construction
• Unbeatable price
• Brushed interior for extra softness

Cons

• Prone to pilling in the wash
• Runs short

It really doesn't get much more classic than Gildan. These sweatshirts have been around for as long as I can remember, and frankly comfort and affordability will never go out of style. At the end of the day, the best part about this easy, basic sweatshirt isn't how cozy, soft, and wearable it is—it's that it has all that for under 13 bucks.

One buyer says: "The Gildan Fleece Crewneck Sweatshirt has quickly become a staple in my wardrobe, delivering unmatched comfort and versatility that makes it an absolute favorite. This sweatshirt is the ultimate cozy essential for any occasion."

Mack Weldon ACE Crew Neck Sweatshirt

Pros

• Also available as a pullover or full-zip
• Stretchy

Cons

• Runs slightly slim and long

When I'm feeling like it's time to wear a sweatshirt, I want the softest option around—more often than not, that means Mack Weldon. Crafted from micro-brushed French terry, this sweatshirt is sure to be one of the softest things your closet will see in the fall and winter months.

One buyer says: "Love this crew neck sweatshirt. Purchased for my husband- he has several of the zip up hoodies and wanted a few pull overs for his collection. Sizing is the same as his other pieces—the material is cozy and a medium weight, perfect for spring and fall, or layering in the winter."

Flint and Tinder Midweight Terry Crewneck Sweatshirt

Pros

• Garment-dyed for a lived-in look and feel
• Double-layer cuffs offer durability

Cons

• Runs slightly slim in the chest and shoulders

Flint and Tinder is a favorite around these parts, and our editors love this sweatshirt as much as we love the brand's sturdy outerwear. This American-made sweatshirt is solid, soft, and durable—everything a sweatshirt should be. Whether you're going on a run, heading into the office, or just chilling on the couch, it's up for any and every task.

Elwood Oversized Core Crewneck Sweatshirt

Pros

• Lived-in look and feel
• Thick, slouchy fabric

Cons

• Runs long

If you're anything like me, you want a sweatshirt that feels roomy, cozy, and warm as hell. Elwood has just that. This style has a lived-in, vintage look and feel (which means it's super-soft), and an oversized fit that's perfect for winter layering; even when you're just dressing down and getting comfy.

Abercrombie & Fitch Essential Crew Sweatshirt

Pros

• Perfectly boxy fit
• Vintage look and feel
• Available in Regular and Tall fits

Cons

• Some buyers dislike the shape
• Fabric is on the thinner side

For layering up on a cold day—or hunkering down on a lazy one. If you want the perfect boxy, vintage-looking sweatshirt, Abercrombie has an infallible pick I keep on coming back to. This is easy to dress down or up, and considering how cozy it is, you're going to find yourself doing both—any excuse to wear it as often as you can.

One buyer says: "One of my favorite crewnecks. I can’t wear it enough! I got my usual jacket size which is a medium and it’s a perfect fit."

Reigning Champ Midweight Terry Crewneck

Pros

• Flatlock seams
• Ribbed trim
• Plenty of color options

Cons

• Runs slim

Simple, minimal, and versatile as hell—whether you pair it with jeans or sweats, this crewneck gets the job done. Reigning Champ's sweatshirt is all about durability, so don't be afraid to wear this one anywhere from the office to the gym.

Lululemon Steady State Crew

Pros

• Breathable fabric
• Roomy fit is great for layering

Cons

• Runs slightly long

For working out or staying in, Lululemon's mid-weight crewneck is the ultimate everyday pick. It's not too heavy but not too light, either, perfect for wearing on your morning jog or a brisk commute. And with a brushed-fleece interior, it's all about maximum comfort, too.

One buyer says: "We love how the sweater keeps its shape after so many washes, it is worth buying high quality products because it lasts forever and always fits so perfectly."

Everlane ReTrack Crewneck Sweatshirt

Pros

• Gets softer over time
• Made with renewed materials

Cons

• Runs slim

Everlane has been an Esquire-editor favorite for essentials for a while now, and this crewneck is no exception. With a relaxed, boxy fit and heavyweight fabric, this cozy sweatshirt is oh so soft but not so dressed down that you couldn't wear it to work with a button-down underneath it.

One buyer says: "Love the ReTrack sweatshirt. Kinda boxy but not overly long. Well made and soft inside. Liked it so much I bought the navy version too. Small gripe would be the logo on the back, outside—got a seam remover and removed the tag. Easily my favorite sweatshirt."

J.Crew Heritage 14 Oz. Fleece Sweatshirt

Pros

• Available in Classic and Tall fits
• Ribbed trim
• Cross-grain construction to prevent shrinkage

Cons

• Fleece interior might be too warm for some

Warm, cozy, and—true to J.Crew's nature—pretty damn chic, too. But, of course, when it comes to imbuing the mundane with a little bit of extra sophistication, J.Crew excels. Dress this up with a button-up underneath, or wear it on its own for a more casual vibe.

One buyer says: "Heavyweight and well constructed. Wears like a hug."

Uniqlo Sweatshirt

Pros

• Looped interior to prevent pilling
• Neck tape designed to retain collar shape

Cons

• Not the warmest option

Uniqlo has mastered the art of basics, and what is a crewneck sweatshirt if not a basic? This relaxed, roomy style is a cozy vibe for a cloudy day. Plus, it's durable as hell; wear this as many times as you want, and then come back for more knowing it'll still look and feel like new.

Alo Yoga Renown Heavy Weight Crew Neck Pullover

Pros

• Heavyweight fabric
• Boxy fit

Cons

• Some buyers recommend sizing down

Here's one that'll truly keep you warm—and it'll keep you stylish, too. Our editors love Alo's range of athleisure, including this comfy, cozy sweatshirt with a minimalist look that'll never go out of style.

One buyer says: "Got an XL it's amazing the quality is perfect and the inside is very soft. The arm sleeve length is perfect but the body length could either be an inch or 2 longer. Or make the bottom of the sweater with the 'band' is heavier since it's a heavyweight."

AG Elba Crewneck Sweatshirt

Pros

• Ribbed trim
• Mid-weight feel

Cons

• Only one color option

In my humble opinion, there's nothing like a cozy, warm brown sweatshirt for autumn. AG takes the lead with this supersoft design that toes the line of between a sweater and a long-sleeved tee. And the quality? Well, that's also perfection.

Stone Island Logo-Appliquéd Cotton-Jersey Sweatshirt

Pros

• Stretchy fabric
• Durable construction
• Logo on the arm

Cons

• Pricey

With its iconic logo patch, this Stone Island sweatshirt is as much a streetwear staple as it is a loungewear one.

Polo Ralph Lauren Garment-Dyed Fleece Sweatshirt

Pros

• Has a patch pocket
• Ribbed trims

Cons

• Limited color options

It's no secret that Polo Ralph Lauren can take your average closet staple and turn it into a chicer, cooler version of itself, and this fleece sweatshirt is no exception to the rule. I'm someone who always appreciates a chest pocket, and PRL does this one with a timeless minimalism. Layer an oxford under this sweatshirt to dress it up, or keep it casual with joggers and sneakers.

Celine Homme Logo-Appliquéd Cotton-Blend Jersey Sweatshirt

Pros

• Dropped shoulder seam for comfort
• Slightly stretchy

Cons

• Pricey

For when you want to elevate your look a little bit, turn to Celine Homme's crewneck sweatshirt. It's simple and classic, but the fitted look and large logo bring an extra layer of chicness.